Key insights
- The article suggests caution towards the RoundHill Magnificent Seven ETF (MAGS) due to its concentrated portfolio and high expense ratio, labeling it a potential investment fad. It favors the Vanguard Information and Technology ETF (VGT) for its diversification and lower expense ratio, despite VGT also being influenced by the 'Magnificent Seven' stocks due to its market-cap weighting. This implies a slightly bearish outlook on concentrated tech bets.
All too often, Wall Street gets sucked into what amounts to investment fads. One of the biggest in history was the so-called Nifty Fifty, a collection of large companies whose stocks investors believed would only go up. Eventually, they fell, to the chagrin of those who got caught up in the hysteria.
Today, there's the Magnificent Seven, which exchange-traded fund (ETF) RoundHill Magnificent Seven ETF (MAGS 1.52%) tracks. Before you get caught up in this modern investment fad, consider the risks. And maybe buy an ETF like Vanguard Information and Technology ETF (VGT 1.04%) instead. Here's what you need to know.
The magnificent seven is simply a list of strongly performing technology stocks. Essentially, investor sentiment is what's driving this list. When investor sentiment changes, as often happens on Wall Street, these magnificent stocks could quickly turn into market dogs. Buying an ETF based entirely on investor sentiment is not a great long-term investment plan. That's particularly true in the technology sector, where new innovation is constant.
And the fact that there are only seven stocks in RoundHill Magnificent Seven ETF makes the risk that much higher. Sure, the concentration has helped on the way up, but it will hurt if, more likely when, these seven stocks are no longer market darlings. To add insult to injury, the expense ratio is a high 0.29%, which seems odd given how little work should be required to manage such a small portfolio.
Vanguard Information and Technology ETF is at the opposite extreme in almost every way. For example, it owns more than 300 stocks and has an expense ratio of just 0.09%. It may not have performed as well as RoundHill Magnificent Seven ETF, but focusing on low costs and diversification is a tried-and-true approach to investing.
That said, Vanguard Information and Technology ETF is market-cap weighted, so the largest companies have the greatest impact on performance. The magnificent seven are important to its performance, too. However, exposure to another 300 or so stocks beyond that short list will allow you to benefit when other tech companies become market darlings. And the diversification will soften the blow when the magnificent seven falter, just like the Nifty Fifty eventually did before them.
Vanguard Information and Technology ETF is built to help you build wealth over time. RoundHill Magnificent Seven ETF is built so people can invest directly in a Wall Street fad. Most investors looking for tech exposure should go with the Vanguard ETF and the tried-and-true methods that have reliably built sustainable wealth over time.